Travel
Moyidea Extendable Ice Scraper Snow Brush
If you’re searching for an ice scraper that will simplify your snow routine, the Moyidea 36-Inch Extendable Ice Scraper is a must-have. It comes in three parts: a handle, a brush attachment, and an ice scraper attachment. You can easily attach and detach the brush and scraper to either end, making it compact enough to store in the off season.
In testing, we found the brush locked in easily, although the scraper took a bit more effort to secure in place.The brush is wider and thicker than previous models we’ve used, and it rotates 360 degrees for extra mobility. The handle is just the right length—not too long, not too short—and it extends from 27 to 36 inches. Plus, it’s wrapped in soft foam for an extra-comfortable grip.
The polypropylene plastic held up well against thick ice, requiring just one pass to clear the area. We found the brush bristles similarly well made, effectively removing thinner layers. After three months of tackling heavy snow and ice, the scraper still looks brand new. Overall, we have no complaints—if you’re looking for a compact, budget-friendly, and effective ice scraper, this is an excellent choice.
Length: 27 to 36 inches | Weight: 1.19 pounds | Features: Pivoting head, snow brush, extendable, cushioned grip
Snow Joe Telescoping Snow Broom + Ice Scraper
The best ice scrapers handle stubborn ice without breaking, scratching, or scuffing. That’s why we love Snow Joe’s 2-in-1 18-Inch Foam Head Telescoping Snow Broom and Ice Scraper. While this is one of the most straightforward models we’ve tested, it’s also one of the highest quality.
We found the scraper to be incredibly durable, and the foam squeegee felt just as long lasting. You can use the sharp scraper to break down tough ice and then brush it off with the foam side—just keep in mind that the brush doesn’t have traditional bristles.
Despite its impressive length, extending up to 52 inches, the scraper felt sturdy and unlikely to break. We also appreciated the padded handle, which provided a much more comfortable grip. After three months of use, the device is still in pristine condition. With its solid construction, this scraper is sure to last for several seasons to come.
Length: 33 to 52 inches | Weight: 1.4 pounds | Features: Extendable, snow broom
Birdrock Home Snow Moover Snow Brush & Ice Scraper
If you drive a larger vehicle, like a truck or van, a small ice scraper just won’t cut it. That’s where the Birdrock Home Snow Moover 55-Inch Extendable Foam Car Snow Brush and Ice Scraper comes in. This scraper extends from 31 and 55 inches. This allowed us to reach nearly every window of our car without having to move our feet. In fact, we cleared every surface in just 10 minutes.
In addition to a standard ice-scraping side, this device also has a brush that rotates 270 degrees, helping you reach every nook and cranny. While the 55-inch length may sound daunting, the attachments can easily come on and off, making it more compact than you’d expect. That said, this option is still on the larger side, so it may be uncomfortable for those with smaller hands.
Length: 31 to 55 inches | Weight: 1.98 pounds | Features: Snow brush, extendable, detachable ice scraper, foam handle
Hopkins Subzero Ice Crusher Ice Scraper
While extendable ice scrapers offer impressive reach, smaller models are easier to travel with and stash in the car. With its lightweight, no-frills design, the Hopkins Subzero 16621 Ice Crusher is perfect for quick tasks.
The small yet mighty scraper has two features: a rigid ice crusher and a flat ice scraper. The crusher side is designed to chip through thick layers of ice while the flat scraper blade excels at clearing surfaces. During testing, we found both sides effective, particularly the flat side. The foam handle was also comfortable to grip and provided more precise control than some of the bulkier models on our list.
Due to its small size, this scraper may require a bit more effort to reach the middle and top of the windshield, particularly on larger vehicles. That said, it’s budget friendly, effective, and durable—even after three months of use, we’ve seen no signs of wear. Plus, it’s compact enough to fit in the side pocket of your car door.
Length: 11 inches | Weight: 0.25 pounds | Features: Ice crusher, ice scraper, foam handle
SubZero Quick Lock Pivoting Head Snowbroom
After three months of use, we can confidently say this two-in-one model is one of the best ice scrapers we’ve ever tried. One side features a classic ice scraper blade with chippers while the other has a pivoting brush and squeegee. This dual brush offers the best of both worlds—classic bristles to get into the crevices and a squeegee to remove moisture.
During testing, this ice scraper proved to be very effective and quick at breaking down ice, while the brush easily cleared away fresh snow and residue. It felt solid, and even after chipping away at heavy ice, there was no visible damage to the blade. The 60-inch pole made it especially easy to reach our car’s roof, and we never worried about it being too flimsy for the job. After months of daily use, it’s still exceeding our expectations.
Length: 60 inches | Weight: 1 pound | Features: Ice crusher, pivoting broom and squeegee, extendable foam handle
Final Verdict
Our top pick is the Moyidea 36-Inch Extendable Ice Scraper Snow Brush, which cleared ice and snow with just one pass. In addition to its durable, well-made design, it also has a pivoting head, an extendable handle, and a padded grip for comfort. For those who need an ice scraper that can handle larger surfaces, we recommend the Birdrock Home Snow Moover Snow Brush and Ice Scraper. With its impressive 55-inch extendable handle, it’s perfect for tackling big windows and windshields.
Our Testing Process
To find the best ice scrapers, we tested 21 models in icy conditions over three months. Upon arrival, we examined the quality of each ice scraper, observing the weight and whether they had features like ergonomic handles and snow brushes.
After the first snowfall, we tried using each ice scraper without turning on our car’s defroster. If unsuccessful, we used the defroster and tried again. We timed how long it took for us to clear each car window of all ice and snow, assessing the ice scraper’s performance on thin and thick ice and how comfortable it was to hold. If the scraper had any additional features, we evaluated whether they made the product more effective.
Once finished, we recorded the approximate thickness of the ice, amount of sun, outside temperature, defrost settings (if applicable), and how many windows we cleared in total. We then repeated the testing process at least two more times (weather permitting) before seeing the product price—the median price of the ice scrapers we tested was $17.
For long-term insights, we continued using the ice scrapers over three months, evaluating their performance and durability over time. Finally, we scored each one based on its performance, durability, features, ease of use, and value, which is based on the product’s performance in conjunction with its retail price. All scrapers were long-term tested over the winter to make sure they held up to daily use.
How to Shop for Ice Scrapers Like a Pro
Size
When choosing an ice scraper, the size of your vehicle should be your first consideration. If you have a larger vehicle, like a truck or van, a bigger, heavy-duty option will be the most effective. An extendable handle is especially useful in these cases, as it allows you to reach more of your windshield without having to move around your car. Just make sure you have ample space in the trunk or backseat to store it.
For those with smaller cars and more limited storage space, a handheld ice scraper, like the Hopkins SubZero 16621 Ice Scraper Ice Crusher, is the best bet. While smaller models may clear less ice at once, they’re lighter and less cumbersome, so your arm won’t get as tired while you clean.
Features
We suggest going with a two-in-one ice scraper and snow brush, which includes both a sharper ice scraper and a bristled brush. The sharp scraper will be best for breaking down more stubborn ice, while the brush is suitable for removing lighter layers of snow. Other features you might find include heating capabilities, LED lights, squeegee attachments, rotating heads, extendable lengths, interchangeable pieces, glove attachments, and crusher or chipper attachments.
Ergonomics
While ice scrapers can sometimes feel uncomfortable and awkward to use, it’s important to find a model with an ergonomic design. All of the models on our list have padded foam on the handles, which allows for a more comfortable grip. It’s also worth considering weight; a lighter scraper will be less cumbersome and easier to handle during extended use.
More Ice Scrapers to Consider
Common'h Ice Scraper with Glove: We found this ice scraper to be both effective and durable, and the warm, waterproof glove kept our hand toasty as we worked. That said, the short handle wasn’t ideal for clearing larger.surfaces
SnoShark-STD: This model excelled at clearing snow, thanks to its metal telescoping handle and nylon paddle. However, it was less effective when it came to clearing ice.
OxGord 2-in-1 Ice Scraper and Snow Brush: Measuring just 17 inches in length, this compact model allowed us to clear snow and ice from our car in less than five minutes. Just keep in mind that due to its small size, it might not be the most practical choice for larger vehicles.
Snow Joe SJBLZD Illum-n LED Lighted 4-in-1 Snow Broom Plus Ice Scraper: Featuring four LED lights, this snow broom and ice scraper combo is perfect for late-night projects. Unfortunately, the ice scraper wasn’t strong enough to handle thick ice, and the metal was quite cold to hold without gloves.
Questions You Might Ask
What features are most important in an ice scraper?
Before you buy, consider which features might benefit your needs. For example, an extendable handle could be necessary for people with larger cars, while LED lights may be essential for those with early morning or late night commutes.
We also want to point out that heated scrapers aren’t worth buying—in our testing, they took a while to heat up and were no more effective than the defroster on our car.
What size ice scraper should I get?
The size ice scraper you choose should largely depend on the vehicle you drive. If you drive a larger vehicle, an extendable ice scraper will make cleaning quicker and easier. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a portable option to keep in your car for quicker tasks, a compact scraper is the way to go.
When should I use the scraper or the brush side?
Most models have two sides—an ice scraper and a brush. The scraping side is sharper, making it great for breaking down ice. In addition to the classic flat blade, some models may also have rigid chippers to help tackle thicker, more stubborn ice.
Once you’ve chipped at the ice, you can use the flat brush side to clear the debris. Some brushes have traditional bristles to help get into the crevices, while others have a smoother design for pushing snow. Some models, like the Hopkins SubZero 80037 60-Inch Quick Lock Pivoting Head Snowbroom, include a bristled brush and squeegee to eliminate excess moisture.
Take Our Word for It
To compile this list, we tested 21 ice scrapers and evaluated them on performance, durability, features, ease of use, and value.
Read More