Fashion & Beauty

3 Differently-Sized Women Try On 5 Pairs of Jeans (+ More) – A Realistic Abercrombie Sizing Review

Image

Drescription

After 12 years of wearing nothing but Madewell jeans, I’ve jumped ship – I’m an Abercrombie & Fitch denim gal now. Before you roll your eyes, let me be clear: this is not the Abercrombie of yore, folks. Gone are the models with abs of steel; gone are the migraine-inducing fragrances; gone are the implications and hints that Abercrombie is a certain type of shopper. Instead, Abercrombie in 2024 is an affordable, size-inclusive destination for easy-to-wear adult basics that won’t break the bank.

But not everyone on the EHD team was convinced – those early aughts mall memories are hard to shake! – so earlier this week, I dragged two of my coworkers to the mall (as one does) where we put Abercrombie’s denim to the test on our 3 normal, non-model bodies. We are each a different shape and different size, but we all found styles that made us feel great! The best part? Everything we tried on is on sale this weekend, through the 12th. (This isn’t even sponsored – I just love these jeans so much and wish someone had told me about them earlier.) Scroll to see our first-hand reviews and try-ons featuring 5 best-selling denim styles, one cute dress, and a perfect-for-fall trench. It’s a real “choose your adventure” kind of post – take a peek at the writer who most closely resembles your shape (our size details are below, obvi!) and HAVE AT IT. (Spoiler: a few pieces we found were too good to leave behind – I’m excited to hear which ones you would have grabbed if you’d been shopping with us!)

The Gals And Their Sizing Stats

Jess

Size: 29/30 (28 in high-waisted Madewell if that helps!)

Height: 5’4″ (I was recently measured with a laser (?) and am having an identity crisis with my 1/4 growth spurt).

Caitlin

Size: 12-16, depending on the fit (usually a 31 or 32 in Madewell!). I have a big ol’ butt and VERY wide hips.

Height: 5’8″

Mal

Size: 26/27 or 2-4

Height: 5’7

The Rating Scale

Before we fully get into the cute clothes. Each piece starts with a group photo with a thumbs up, thumbs “meh”, and thumbs down. We also have a 0 to 5 rating in our individual reviews but just wanted to give you all the info!

The 90s Straight Ultra High Rise (Curve Love)

Jess

Size: 29/8R (I could have size up probably)

Fit: They fit really great! Sure, I should have tried on a “short” style because they were waaayy too long and would have needed to be hemmed which is always annoying. I just cuffed them for these photos. Overall I liked the cut and that they were high-waisted but not too high-waisted. And as the resident flat-butted gal of the group, I didn’t have any real issues in that area. Sure, it didn’t enhance it really but that didn’t bother at all. A great everyday jean. Had I needed a pair of jeans I would have bought these.

Rating: 4/5

Caitlin

Size: 32/14R

Fit: My fellow wide-hipped women will understand my struggle – it’s HARD to find a true straight jean! My eyes just kept going straight to that curve around my thighs – I felt really jealous of how the jeans fell on Jess and Mal. (I still maintain that these are STUNNING on Jess’ shape and that she should have brought them home!) That said, I am super thankful for the Curve Love line – lord knows this booty would not be fittin’ into regular jeans without that extra 2″ of give – but despite their comfort, these felt like a pass for me. BIG MEH.

Rating: 3/5

Mal

Size: 26

Fit: These jeans fit well in the front and I REALLY loved the wash but ultimately it fit a lil weird on the booty area. I just felt like it didn’t quite do the things it needed to back there (shape, lift, etc) and instead, it just felt a lil tight (the seam kind of buckled in a weird way around the mid-butt lol). So basically if you’ve got a booty I’d recommend snagging a different pair :)

Rating: 2/5

The ’90s Relaxed (Curve Love)

Jess

Size: 30/10R

Fit: Not terrible but also not good. They weren’t baggy enough to feel cool and not fitted enough to show off the goods. This style has really never worked more. I need more shape!

Rating: 2.5/5

Caitlin

Size: 32/14R

Fit: Seeing these now, I can’t totally recall why I gave them a full thumbs down! They are…fine. Again, it just feels like my legs are filling these out a little too much to consider them “relaxed.” They do get points for being ultra comfortable, but they’re not really giving me a confidence boost, you know?

Rating: 2/5

Mal

Size: 26

Fit: If you couldn’t tell from the last rating, one of my biggest things when it comes to the fit of a jean is how it looks on the bootay. I’m looking for a pair that makes that thing POP in the best of ways and doesn’t leave weird lines/make it look like you’re wearing a diaper. For this reason, I’m not THAT into baggy/relaxed fitting jeans – I’d rather go for a straight leg or wide leg that’s still tailored up top and then flows toward the bottom. So the reason I gave these a side thumbs up is because for baggy jeans I REALLY liked them and thought they didn’t look horrible in the back, but I don’t wear baggy jeans all that much so that is why I’m knocking them 2 points.

Rating: 3/5

Denim Dress

Jess

Size: Large

Fit: I only tried on this little number because Caitlin wanted me to. Not only is it a cut that really isn’t my style or preference, but it was also a size too big. It’s comically terrible on me lol. I loved how it looked on Caitlin and Mal though and the fabric quality was great! I think that it was also too long for my 5’4″ height. I don’t think wearing a medium would have made it short enough.

Rating: 0/5 (just on me!)

Caitlin

Size: Large

Fit: OKAY, I LOVE! (And I bought.) If anyone has ever called you “hot” or “sexy,” this cut will probably not be up your alley. But as a lifelong “cute” gal, this is a slam dunk. I can’t wait to wear it solo for the rest of the summer, and I’m really looking forward to layering it with turtlenecks or Peter Pan collars and a cozy pair tights in the fall. But be warned that it does run LARGE – I’m getting a few inches taken in on the waist! Overall: great length, not clingy, and the perfect throw-and-go dress.

Rating:

Mal

Size: Small

Fit: This dress was VERY comfy and super cute. I thought it looked very flattering on everyone, but in my opinion, it just needed some accessorizing (a gold necklace? a lil sweater like the one I tied around the waist??) and then it looked super polished.

Rating: 4/5

The Baggy (Curve Love)

Jess

Size: 30/10R

Fit: After looking back at these photos, I actually like these jeans more! I think these were the cutest on all three of us. The wash is that perfect medium tone, the hem is fun and I like where the waist sits. Again, as a short gal, I would go for the short size but these are a great cool and causal pair! Trendy without trying too hard.

Rating: 4/5

Caitlin

Size: 31/12R

Fit: I actually really liked these! Under normal circumstances – you know, before I realized that pants that fit my body existed – I would have brought them home, thrilled to have found an on-trend style that doesn’t cling. They’re baggy without being TOO baggy and they still give you some shape on the bum. The only downside was that mine gapped a bit in the back, which I didn’t love (I think they might have a slightly lower rise than I normally opt for).

Rating: 4/5

Mal

Size: 25/0S

Fit: Remember when I said I don’t love baggy jeans? Well I sized down, they became not baggy and I LOVE THEM (AND BOUGHT THEM!!!) I’ve been looking for some more mid-rise jeans since all of my jeans are VERY high-waisted and these guys are literally perfect. Plus the hem at the bottom is just so cute and cool!! They’re also very stretchy so they’re super comfortable, not like that tough Levi’s kinda denim. Praise be! Buy these!

Rating: 5/5

The Loose High Rise Jean

Jess

Size: 30/10R

Fit: They are a really nice mix of fitted and slightly loose (I guess I could have sized up more looseness)! I also liked that they were high rise but on me not too high rise if you know what I mean. They didn’t do much for enhancing my behind but given the style and my lack of more rounded bum, I wasn’t too surprised. I wish I had tried them in the short length because as you can see I do not have long limbs:) I just don’t need jeans at the moment so it was a pass for me.

Rating: 3.5/5

Caitlin

Size: 31/12R (Curve Love)

Fit: Confession: You remember the header photo? I’m wearing my own pair of Loose Jeans in it! I was excited to try on a darker wash, and they don’t disappoint. I’ve been stopped countless times in these pants by women with similar body types who’ve asked where I bought them – it’s an honor to help spread the word. :) I might prefer this cut in lighter washes, but you can’t find a more comfortable pair of jeans – have suffered through some 100-degree days in the woodshop without complaints because they’re so easy to wear!

Rating: 4.5/5

Mal

Size: 26

Fit: Never have I ever hated a jean more on me. The weird flare at the bottom. The diaper effect on the butt. Hard pass. Also, lol, that my shirt kept covering all of the jeans so I keep having to lift it up. Next time I’m wearing a white tank like Caitlin.

Rating: 1/5

The Ultra Loose Low Rise

Jess

Size: 30/10R (Curve Love)

Fit: LOLOL Noooooo! I don’t think I need to convince of you why these weren’t a fit for me. Partially, I think the Curve Love style for these added too much width on me but my height makes it hard for really baggy pants to look good on me. I actually have a pair from Zara I love but these were never going to come home with me. But man are they SO CUTE on Caitlin and Mal!

Rating: 0/5

Caitlin

Size: 30/10 (Blue) + 31/12 (Black) (Curve Love)

Fit: I went on a JOURNEY with these – I started with some in size 14 (pictured in our group shot with my arm in the air) which were FAR too big, but also kind of cool? (My underwear band was peeking out, Calvin-style, and the gals said I looked like I belonged in Silver Lake, which I didn’t disagree with – they had a lil’ je ne sais quoi!) I ended up swapping for Jess’ 10 in blue which fit BEAUTIFULLY – they’re by far the best wide-leg jeans I’ve ever tried on! – and then I tried a 12 in the black, which I ended up purchasing. If you’re pear-shaped, strong-hipped, or large-butted, the Ultra Loose is THE JEAN FOR YOU. I felt awesome in them. (PS. If you’re under 5’6, I’d actually suggest the standard Loose Jean – I think my extra height helps me pull off the width on these!)

Rating: 6/5 (Yeah, I loved them THAT much. Madewell who?!)

Mal

Size: 26

Fit: These made my knees feel so weirdly exposed and I’m just not used to that sensation. All in all I think for a ripped, baggy jeans these are a pretty good option! I’m just not really a ripped baggy jean person is what I’ve discovered from this :)

Rating: 3/5

Denim Trench

Jess

Size: Medium

Fit: I really loved it!! It’s just oversized enough to comfortably wear a sweater underneath. It truly looks like a real trench but in a much cooler fabric:) If I lived in a cooler place it would have come home with me.

Rating: 5/5

Caitlin

Size: Large

Fit: You know how I loved the earlier dress, and it wasn’t a fit for Jess? This is the EXACT SAME situation with a reverse outcome. I just don’t have the gravitas to pull off a denim trench. Was it well-made? Yes! Was it a great price for the quality? Yup! Will I ever have the need to cloak myself in a denim top layer? Probably not. But if you need one, this would be a great pick!

Rating: 3/5

The trench was a no for Mal so this is where we leave you! We clearly had a great time but mostly hope that this gives you the confidence to try out Abercrombie if you are looking for some new denim or other cute clothes. Let us know if you’ve had good experiences with the new and improved Abercrombie too!

Related Post

Image
Fashion & Beauty

Our “Non Try-Hard” Ways To Feel Sexy – From 7 Different EHD Women

This post (and the upcoming Valentine’s Day) may as well be sponsored by Bridgerton. If you’ve watched it you’ll know what I’m talking about as all my girlfriends have expressed how it has positively affected their marriage (I espoused this a couple years with Outlander, as well). Listen, being quarantined we all know that keeping the spark up can be challenging – so much time together, in sweats, and if you have kids it’s even harder. Regardless of your relationship status, if you are looking for ways to feel more comfortable and sexy without the straps and cuffs (certainly no judgment here), then the EHD team has collected some ideas for you, from those of us who are comfortable enough/had something to share. And if the idea of this post makes you uncomfortable (or if you are our dads) just come back tomorrow – we think that normalizing female conversations around having a healthy sex life is a good thing, but I get that it’s not everyone’s cup of tea. I’ll go first. Pre-game Products I want to feel smooth and soft, so I normally use a dry brush to exfoliate then in the bath (I love this bubble bath after trying 16), I shave with this razor, I just got this waxing kit I’m going to try soon (I’m scared!) and then I use this lotion which smells SO GOOD. I also generally put on this tanning lotion (don’t forget the mitt) once a week in winter (more often in summer) to give me a bronz-ey glow that makes me feel good. But it does have that self-tan scent so I’d recommend applying it a day or two in advance then showering and putting on your scent. I also love putting this Aqua Parma on after that which gives a shimmer that is so pretty and subtle. Also a huge fan of Jo Malone bath oil. To Wear (Or Not To Wear) Besides the super special occasions (which are hard to do in Covid) I need to feel super comfortable. I just recently bought 3 pairs of the same pajamas (that I’ve been raving about for over a year) because they are so thin, SO soft, and cozy (HOT TIP – the fabric ‘modal’ is what I look for now). And while I think that no Cis male (or any male) would consider those “sexy”, per se, they are so thin and soft and cut in NOwhere (and easily come off), so for the less suspecting/planned nights, these are great. But for Valentine’s day (and for this post) I did a LOT of shopping online and found so few that I felt were flattering and yet comfortable and “me”. If you want to know what I bought and kept – what I found comfortable (I can’t with the underwire right now) and flattering it’s THIS romper and this top and bottom set. I also love the lines of this set that looks soft and pretty that I ordered but haven’t received yet. The Shocking “Sleepwear” Winner Speaking of unsuspecting…last year I got a cami and underwear set in a swag bag from a press party and I only opened it a couple months ago. I quite literally couldn’t believe how soft, thin and forgiving they were. When I looked at who makes this magical set it said ‘Jockey’ and I was like ‘well surely this is a collaboration with Goop or Doen or something’ but nope. They are REALLY thin, stretchy, and soft (not tight AT ALL, but not baggy – I don’t get it). I bought 3 sets and they feel like soft naked butter on your skin – Brian LOVES them despite how boring they are. AND they stay put! It’s not like they are so loose that they ride up, they are just so comfortable you don’t notice them in any way. Not too loose, not too tight – the sisterhood of the traveling cami set for all of us. To Set The Mood Bedding: Brooklinen percale sheets and duvet are my normal crisp, cool, and super soft go-to. I recently tried Buffy eucalyptus duvet and insert are both super comfortable if not more slick (not satin, but definitely more slick if that makes sense). And if you like the linen feel EHD loves the Casaluna line (but Brian prefers percale over linen). Candles: I keep one of these on my bath tray and light it every time I bathe (far more frequently than ever before) and then another on my nightstand. I like that there’s 3 wicks and they smell so good. Books: I’ve been reading steamy romance novels since I was 11 so I’m quite experienced in this. Most of my friends (including myself) enjoyed The Wedding Date series, and if you are bored and haven’t read 50 Shades, well, I’ll see you in 2 weeks when you come up for air. From Arlyn: Nars Velvet Matte Lipstick Pencil in Cruella: It might be a bit silly to slather on lipstick for myself and my four walls (well, and my husband), but I did this a few weeks ago and felt more myself than I have in 10 months. I felt powerful, confident, sexy. Cruella has been “my” color for the better part of seven years, and on days where I feel plain and meh, it sets me right. This bra + these underwear: Challenge: Wear a set of matching bra and undies and just try not to feel like a superhero. Just try…YOU CAN’T. This is my #1 “sexy” trick, whether for myself or for my marriage. The set doesn’t even have to be particularly scandalous or risque. Just the fact that you’re pulled together enough to have a bra and a pair of underwater that match that are clean at the same time, well…that’d get anyone to feel themselves, amiright? Bonus points if there’s a cheeky cut or some lace involved. Glossier You fragrance: I’m sure I’m not the only one here listing perfume. It’s low-hanging fruit, but that fruit hangs low for a reason. I used to be a daily spritzer, you know, pre-hermit Arlyn was at least. And recently, I eyed a bottle of one of my favorite fragrances right now and said “what the heck” and spritzed myself happy. Even if it’s just for you, what reason do you have to not smell good for yourself? Self-care baby. However, if you do have a partner, don’t be surprised if you walk past the room they’re in, and their legs involuntarily stand them up to follow you wherever you’re going, hypnotized…it smells that good. From Ajai: Neutrogena Hydro Boost Cleansing Towelettes: If I can be candid about the situation, after having a child, personal hygiene can be tough to maintain. Handling a newborn makes me forget what day it is and if I took a shower, so these hydro boost cleansing towelettes have really come in handy. If my face and neck get sweaty throughout the day I love whipping these babies out. I can even use them to wipe off the breast milk that lives everywhere on my skin. These towelettes leave my skin glowing – my husband compliments me after almost every use. I smell, feel, and look good (sexy) after I use them. Le Labo – Santal 26 Candle & Le Labo – Bergamot 22 Perfume: When I gave birth to our little one I had a c-section, so I’m not able to take baths to relax as I continue to heal. That said, scents have always been a big deal to me and I’ve been getting my fix with candles and perfumes. I love lighting my Santal 26 candle, in addition to (when I am able to take a shower) spraying on my Bergamote 22 perfume. Both of these scents make me feel so good, confident, and sexy. Sephora – Cream Lip Stain – 27 – Black Cherry: Nowadays, I love putting this on for zoom meetings and FaceTime calls with friends and family. This color makes me feel like a real boss-lady and a darn sexy mama. It’s very chic, perfect for fall and winter, and I get so many compliments on this color when I wear it. From Ryann: Oversized Button Up: This is going to sound pretty funny, but I recently bought a striped oversized men’s button up from Goodwill that’s super soft and comfy and turns out I feel effortlessly sexy in it. I’ve tried the lingerie thing and sure, it’s fun but sometimes it feels too performative and without a little liquid courage, it’s hard to not feel silly/self-conscious. So, a button-up with pretty underwear is my go-to and makes me feel cute and sexy. Body Scrub: This body scrub is nothing special or fancy, but I got it for Christmas and both my fiancé and I love how it smells plus it makes my skin feel really soft. For some reason, I am really lazy about putting body lotion on, but when I use this scrub I love following it up with body butter so I feel extra pampered. Parade Underwear: There’s a good reason this brand is all over Instagram. I have three pairs but I wish I had a hundred because they are so soft and comfortable and I think I feel best when I am just walking around my apartment in a little t-shirt and these undies. The mesh side detail is also very cute and sexy. From Rashida: Lately I’ve been retiring my natural curls for wand curls, and it’s created a new woman, a new identity that makes me feel very sexy. Package the wand curls with my favorite matte red lip, and my black squared neckline top, and you can’t tell me nothing!! From Mallory: Cowl Neck Top: If there’s one thing I LOVE this a cowl neck top. If you’re in my club, IBTC (itty-bitty-titty-committee) this one is for you. Wearing a big ol’ pushup bra can make me feel sexy but NOT wearing a bra can also make me feel sexy (plus it’s wayyy more comfortable). I love wearing cowl neck tops like this because they’re low-cut without being like uh your boobs are out PLUS the fit of the shirt automatically gives you extra zhuzh up top. I wear this all the time (even in Covid). Bra: On the flip side, a bra with some padding makes me feel sexy since it’s basically doubling the size of my ladies. This one from the one and only Victoria’s Secret is great because it comes in lots of colors and fits in the comfiest way (especially for a push up) From Sara: Multi Benne Stick: This lip stain from NOTO is a little dark, really soft, and kissable, and exactly what I swipe on for date nights. Stargazer Lily: Mac got me this perfume oil for my birthday this year, and I find myself rolling it on right before I get into bed all the time. It’s a really sensual, deep heady floral scent, but it’s not overwhelming. To me it smells like a humid summer night – think “The Notebook” Huggie Hoops: I bought these for myself a few months ago, and haven’t taken them off since. Wearing gold hoops makes me feel close to my mom, grandma, and female relatives in Guatemala (where my first pair of gold hoops were sent from as a baby gift when I was just 3 weeks old). A pair of gold hoops are a part of my daily armor, and make me feel very much myself. Well, there you have it. All the scents, intimates, clothing, jewelry, etc that make US feel good and sexy. What makes you feel good? There are no wrong answers and we’d love to know.

Read More
Image
Home Decor

Design Coaching: Peter And Chrissy’s Builder-Grade Kitchen Plan (I’ve Got Thoughts!)

Oh boy, this is fun. I love inserting myself into other people’s problems (usually when asked) so this whole “help someone else design their house” thing is already making my dopamine spike. After sifting through countless submissions (sooo many good ones–thank you to all who applied!), battling weeks of email hacking snafus, and balancing our super stacked schedule, we FINALLY found our match. You can read about this sweet couple here! To refresh your memory Chrissy and Peter, our first participants in the Renovation Coach series, have 3 kids under the age of 3, really good taste, and enough experience with remodeling to not hire a contractor. And yet, like all of us, doing it alone feels daunting and scary (because it simply is the nature of the beast). About The House The house was built in the 90s and has an addition and some awkward angles and finishes for sure. But the neighborhood is great and the lot is HUGE. They want to change a lot about the house – adding a primary bedroom, moving the powder bath, adding a mudroom, moving the washer/dryer upstairs, and redoing the kitchen (maybe more, but that’s what came out of the 2-hour initial session). For our purposes, we are talking kitchen, but it was so good to know what else they were thinking – how long will this string be?? For total visual context of the space before we get into the ins and out of this kitchen, here is a video of the space! (just wait for the ads to play:)) Back To The Kitchen (Pre-Move-In) Here’s how it looked when they first moved in. From the drop ceiling to the weirdly shaped island to the unfortunate, immovable structural elements, the kitchen was not their fantasy – both in function and style. Their biggest complaint has been the lack of storage but truly it all needs updating–countertops, cabinets, appliances, flooring, you name it. The flow is a bit weird overall and they’re open to reimagining the space entirely. Oh, and the cabinets are falling apart. “BUILDER-GRADE” (she shakes her fists at the sky). They’ve already made some killer changes, starting with the floor. They opted for this beautiful wide plank wood flooring, getting rid of the checkerboard, which only enhanced the datedness of the kitchen, but also opened up options. By changing the direction of the wood floors it also really helped to better connect the kitchen to the living areas. Here is what their kitchen looked like the day we stopped by to check it out. As you can see, they are mid-project and have been agonizing over the best solution for this space to keep moving forward. They’ve explored a number of layouts and have yet to land on the right one (her keynote collages look like mine – abundant and messy a la A Beautiful Mind. When we first got there she had a plan and two hours later we totally changed it (for the better, we think). Chrissy’s First Mockup (Pre-Meeting) Christy wanted to extend the size of the kitchen into the space next door (which seemed to be initially intended for a dining room). Desperate for storage and a nice big island for cooking and entertaining, they thought that this could be a good solution. I didn’t, TBH, especially because once you get into the space the biggest issue is two different ceiling levels. The dropped and vaulted ceiling is really the culprit here. Well, actually it’s just a regular 8ft ceiling in the kitchen zone that feels like a dropped ceiling because the rest of the space is vaulted. But this cross section is definitely structural, holding up part of their kids’ room upstairs, so they have to find a way to work with it. There were some other issues, as well that they wanted to address. Speaking of structural, both the wall attached to the stairs and this diagonal corner wall connecting to their current washer/dryer closet, have to stay. In this back area is the entrance from their garage, a tight walk-thru, with laundry on one side (that they want to be moved upstairs) and a teeny tiny powder bath on the other. Ideally, they’d love to find a way to add a mudroom in this area…but one project at a time. My perspective was that all these little moves would end up costing $250k at least and not all of them were worth it. Moving a powder bath 5 feet could cost $25k (could also be less, but you just don’t know) so I advised against it unless they were 100% sure this was their “forever home”. Stepping into the kitchen, this is your main view: a bank of tired cabinets, the sink, the dishwasher, and a view that overlooks the dogs’ potty zone. (Did I mention they have two cute pups?) The whole house actually gets really great light exposure from the many windows in the living room, and Chrissy hasn’t loved looking out into this area. They’ve discussed removing this window entirely (or maybe the one in the dining room) or just shifting it over to make room for their ideal cabinet layout. Regardless, they will put in new windows should they keep them here. Plumbing will likely stay on this back wall to keep costs and complications down. But they want to shift the sink over, swapping it for a bigger/better one, then flanking it with a panel-ready dishwasher and trash drawer. And of course, all of this means new cabinets, countertops, hardware, appliances, etc. Again, here is their last mood board (which is rapidly changing, per the usual design process). Chrissy has great taste and design eye – I loved her mockup. None of these elements are final except for the style/color of the cabinetry. The one thing they know for sure is that they love the AXSTAD blue kitchen cabinets from IKEA. The price is right and the look and color really speak to them. Us too. Initially, she wanted to extend the cabinetry all the way across, into the vaulted ceiling dining area, creating a bar zone and prep area with more storage. But she’s struggled with the right combination of cabinets that will align with that ceiling height jump in a visually pleasing way. Additionally, they are losing the corner cabinets, instead shifting the oven zone in line with the back wall to create more of a galley-style kitchen. In order to make this work and look right, they will need to address this weird wall situation and plan to bump it out to make it flush with the walkway opening. Doing this will also add about a foot of space to the powder bath on the other side (another project they have plans for, but again, one thing at a time!). Another part of Chrissy’s design (and we are definitely aligned here) is to keep the island. Well, this funky island will not be staying, but a new rectangular island will take its place. Again, one of their big issues is having enough storage, so prioritizing extra cabinetry here makes sense. They talked about keeping the stools where they are currently, but Gretchen had the idea to build in the overhang at the end of the island instead, near the garage entrance. Enough room for the kiddos to have a seat on a couple of stools while dad cooks, and plenty of room to stand and gather around the back of the island when entertaining–which they do a lot of–while maximizing storage along the backside. The cooktop would stay here (though at one point in our meeting, we discussed swapping it with the sink but that would likely be too much of a ha$$le). Behind the island is their “pantry”, in quotes because it’s more of a Harry Potter closet than a pantry, positioned in the void under the stairs. In all of Chrissy’s plans, integrating a new pantry cabinet was a staple of her design. If you scroll back up to her mockup, she originally envisioned it next to the paneled fridge, likely coming out past the 8ft ceiling divide. The problem then became making it look right with the vaulted ceiling. Would it come up past the 8ft and intersect with the vault? Or stay the same height? Does IKEA even make cabinets to fit a situation like this? And how would this all shake out measurement-wise? Well, Gretch suggested instead turning the original stair/pantry wall into a grand wall of floor-to-ceiling-pantry cabinets, closing off the existing door, and moving its access to the side hallway with some clever angled doors or drawers. Both Chrissy and Peter perked up at this. Of course, it will all have to make sense dimensionally and could be impacted based on the size of the new island. And it means more projects. But it could be a very cool statement moment and would give the chef something more interesting to stare at than the current situation. With more storage going in the island and the potential for a larger pantry area across it, the initial bar/cabinetry build-out into the living space now becomes less crucial. But the problem still remains. How do you integrate this living area with the kitchen so it feels cohesive and connected? Ending the cabinets in the same place as they are now might keep the kitchen feeling small. But extending it into a wet bar or just more counter space isn’t super functional if they also need this area to hold their dining table. Sure, it’d give them more storage but it’s unlikely they’d actually use it for prep space. Our Solution? So what if instead, it became a built-in dining banquette, flanked with cabinets and shelving? This might feel more visually intentional than closed-off cabinets and could address the ceiling shift in a way that makes sense–to us at least. Remember, Chrissy is not married to this window staying here, so a new window could shift around or it could leave altogether and make room for a matching bookcase to flank either side of the bench (with the window in the middle?). The bench (and the shelves) would provide even more storage, but could also turn this wall into a really beautiful, thoughtful focal point. So that’s where we left them, with plenty of new ideas and potential solutions swirling. The biggest question now is how does this all fit together?? Does that wall really have the right length for a double oven, sink, trash drawer and dishwasher, drawers, panel-ready fridge, open shelving bookcase (that starts at exactly the right spot with the weird ceiling shift), plus a built-in dining bench? How big should the island be? Can a grand pantry wall fit into the mix? Their Homework We were so excited about the layout change, but Chrissy really needed to figure out math-wise if they could fit their appliances AND the cabinets in the same kitchen footprint, utilizing the island for the cooktop and knowing that we’d have more storage in the new pantry and the floor-to-ceiling library cabinet focal moment in the dining room. We can’t really do much until we know that the layout will work within the footprint (we all feel hopeful). They have to do some homework to get all of those answers, so we’ll check back in with them soon. I also tasked them with taking an inventory of their kitchen things, what all they’ll need to store, and mapping it out based on the new proposed design — a practice we swear by! Maybe they’ll find they don’t have so much of a storage issue after all? As I was writing this I realized that this is a LOT to try to understand without you being in the space. If you’ve made it this far you are as invested as we are. With 3 kids under three years old, attempting a kitchen remodel is a doozy (thus me wanting to help). They think they can get it done in under 3 months and I’m loving their enthusiasm. They aren’t hiring a GC and instead are going to hire subcontractors and manage the project themselves, which honestly I think will make it go faster if they are on top of it and certainly could save them some money. They have already started getting bids and making relationships with subs and honestly, we all know that no one can get shit done faster than a mom, so maybe the 3 kids under 3 years will actually prove to be the motivation to drive fast. Regardless, we are along for this ride and hoping to not just be a backseat driver. Next up is seeing the update on the layout with our new plan and then we’ll go shopping for tile and stone (assuming that we are good to use the IKEA kitchen). Since this is the first time we are documenting someone else’s project (and not doing renderings, etc) let us know if you have suggestions on the rollout of this – it’s a lot of information to get so we’ll try to break it down so you can weigh in and also gleam any help for your own project. A huge thanks to Chrissy and Peter for being our guinea pigs:)

Read More
Image
Gardening

The Best Gardening Tip I Ever Got Was From My Neighbor, and My Harvests Grow More Every Year

Twenty years ago, when I announced to our neighbor—a spirited Pennsylvania Dutch farmer and World War II veteran—that I was going to start a garden, the first thing he told me was not to plant my tomatoes before Memorial Day. Given that tomatoes start to appear at local nurseries as early as late April—around the time when the last spring frost occurs in our area—that seemed a bit late, but I followed Ethelbert’s advice and never veered from it. Thanks to his advice, I've been harvesting a bountiful crop every year for more than two decades. The Best Gardening Tip I Ever Got As I learned more about the growing conditions of crops, I understood that just because there is no more frost does not mean the weather is conducive to growing tomatoes yet. Tomatoes thrive in warm temperatures between 65°F and 85°F during the day, and 60°F to 70°F at night. In northeast Pennsylvania, where I live, it is not unusual for temperatures to drop below 50°F in May. Cool weather does not often kill the plants, but even one night of cold stunts their growth. I usually buy my tomato plants just before Mother’s Day and keep them in a small portable greenhouse. On warm days, I open the greenhouse all the way, and during the nights, I close it. On especially cold nights, I cover the entire greenhouse with a couple of old sheets. As a result, I am spared what folks who planted earlier go through—they anxiously watch the weather forecast and scramble to cover their tomatoes in the garden on chilly nights. After Memorial Day, the tomatoes are out of the woods temperature-wise. Want more gardening tips? Sign up for our free gardening newsletter for our best growing tips, troubleshooting hacks, and more! How to Control the Growth of Tomato Plants Tomatoes that are planted when the weather is warm start visibly growing after a few days to a week (in less-than-ideal conditions, it takes longer). Once that happens, it’s key to check on them at least every other day because the plants grow at an astounding pace and indeterminate tomato plants turn into a messy jungle and if you don’t support and prune them. I am not a big fan of tomato cages because I find that they constrict the airflow within the plant too much, which encourages the spread of diseases. Instead, I drive a 6-foot steel fence post into the ground for each tomato plant and then tie the main branches to it individually. It’s more work but it pays off, also with easy harvesting. The other element of tomato care is regular pruning. It is not optional—it's an absolute must. In years when I was too busy to keep up with removing the suckers, I paid the price later when I struggled to tame an overgrown plant with excessive foliage and few tomatoes. 4 Tips I Wish I Had Been Given as an Amateur Gardener Since I am indebted to Ethelbert for his great advice, I've compiled a list of four tips I wish I had been given at the start of my gardening journey to pass onto others. Mulch Your Vegetable Garden Hardwood chip mulch does an excellent job at keeping soil moisture in and suppressing weeds, around ornamental and edible crops. I only started it a few years ago when I was able to get free arborist chips from a local tree removal company that was happy to find a place to drop them. Unlike commercial mulch that you purchase at a nursery or garden center, fresh arborist chips are less processed and packed with nutrients, and stay open enough to let in rain, but pack tightly enough to block weeds. Keep Watering New Plants As a new gardener, I followed the standard recommendation of watering immediately after planting, but would let a few days pass before watering again for a days after that. Now, when there is no substantial rain, I water new perennials and annuals every day for about a week, and longer in hot weather. Since I have been more diligent with watering, I have had fewer losses. Focus on Natives In my early days of gardening, I planted just about anything I found attractive that fit our hardiness zone. Looking back, I wish I had been aware of native plants earlier. Today, I am only planting native plants. They are much better adapted to our local climate, have fewer disease and pest issues, have tremendous wildlife value, serve as homes to hundreds of insects important to our food chain, and they are just as beautiful as any introduced species. Wait Out Seasonal Pests Every spring, the wild arugula I was so looking forward to had hundreds of tiny holes chewed by flea beetles that it became inedible. Then I realized that the pest is less active in the fall, and voila! If I plant arugula for a fall harvest, there are almost no flea beetles around. Similarly, I spent lots of time plucking Japanese beetles off my raspberry plants in mid-summer, not knowing that the beetles are gone by the time large and juicy fall-bearing raspberries ripen, so I can save myself that effort.

Read More
Image
Home Decor

Gretch’s Next MOTO: The Bedroom Switch Up

Timing is everything, and that’s also true in design. A little over a year ago, in April, to be exact, I revealed my first Makeover Takeover–my bedroom. I had moved into my place a few months prior and was so excited to have the opportunity to design my room from the ground up, so soon after moving in. It felt like perfect timing. I was (and still am) absolutely in love with how the space turned out. I scored some incredible furniture pieces from Article (a sick storage bed, the coolest floating headboard, and the dresser of my dreams), plus enough fabric to completely cover my walls and then some. It was awesome! But a year and two months of living in a space, even in a room you LOVE, can tend to reveal some things. Namely, how wrong I was in making the smaller room my bedroom, with the stubbed toes to prove it. I consider myself lucky to reside in a two-bedroom apartment, where both rooms are mine to do with as I please. When I moved from my last spot, “more livable space” was high on my wishlist. I’d had a garage previously, which was AWESOME but very dangerous. Not in the sense that anything could harm me (except maybe the rats, damp/crumbling walls, and broken/exposed pipes…okay maybe it was a little dangerous). But when you have a ton of extra space, especially the kind disconnected from daily life (a garage), it is alarmingly easy to fill it with extra stuff. And for me, that is very dangerous. (Later this week, Em will dive into an assessment of her own stuff, which is initially what inspired me to take a closer look at mine, so definitely check that out when it’s live!) When I had the garage, I was working a variety of freelance creative jobs and was heavily into flipping furniture and selling vintage decor on Facebook Marketplace. Having a workshop space was ideal and necessary for how I made a living. But soon enough, I started working for Em, and that garage space just wasn’t needed anymore. And yet somehow I convinced myself that most of what lived inside still was. A handful of unfinished projects, paint cans with some life left (debatable), a huge collection of vintage wares (and soooo much more) came with me to the new spot. When it was time to choose which room would serve as my bedroom and the other as my “studio”, it made more sense to me at the time to pile my mountains of crap into the larger space, thinking I would eventually turn it into a state-of-the-art creative zone and office, with plenty of room to spread out and work. Fast forward a bit, and I can barely walk inside. The in-home studio I envisioned earned its new name, The Doom Room, in record time. A place where all of my extra things went to die, disappearing out of sight and out of mind as soon as I shut the door. No systems, all chaos. And when chaos lives next door, even the dreamiest of bedrooms will begin to suffocate you. After a year in my beautiful room, I began to feel the walls closing in, and not because of the wallpaper, no complaints there–but the lack of wiggle room, in both spaces. My storage bed is so functional, but not if the drawers will only open when all of the dresser drawers across it are closed. Then there’s my clothes closet–the true catalyst for the switch up. If hang up one more romper, and I promise you that wooden rod will SNAP. I literally have to fist fight my t-shirts daily to get them back behind closed doors. And I’m sick of it!! Sick of traversing the narrow walkways of my tiny room, carved out by my big, beautiful bed. Sick of the piles of stuff ignored next door, filling the room with more and more doom every second. Sick of the overall lack of breathing room, accidental injuries, and impenetrable wall of garments. Caitlin’s closet confidential had awoken something in me. Em’s recent prop/carriage house assessment inspired me. Tripping one too many times in both of my rooms drove me insane enough to need a change. Sometimes you really just have to empty everything out, take stock, trim alllll the fat and put back only what’s really important to you, with care (and a bit of a cut-throat mentality) while trying your darnedest not to add more stuff to the stuff. Then step-and-repeating every few years because consumerism has us in a chokehold, and this is a lesson I never seem to be done learning. So that’s my plan! This is the official kick-off of my MOTO: Take 2. A reassessment. And my first step is to purge. My neighborhood is having a garage sale this weekend, and it’s the perfect opportunity (hell yes, deadline) to decide what really deserves to take up space in my life and home. Then it’s another small room challenge–this time a guest room/office that is actually useable and inspired. I want to live in a livable space! My biggest priority is having a bedroom I can actually walk around in, and plenty of room to sit back and admire the pieces I love so much, with the ability to use the drawers (all of them, at the same time) without stubbing my damn toe! I don’t have a solid design plan for either space. Concepts of a plan, sure. What I know for a fact is that all of the major elements of my first MOTO design will live on. I will not be parting ways with my bedroom furniture, only migrating it. I am not exaggerating when I say: these are some of the best pieces I’ve ever owned and still look as good as the day I got them. The headboard, storage bed, and dresser–they’ll live on in the bigger room for a chance to really shine! I will also NOT be touching the wall fabric in the smaller room. This hasn’t budged since the day I installed it (a year ago! With just liquid starch, a bucket, and a paint roller!), and I don’t intend to remove it anytime soon. But it’s totally renter-friendly, and when I am ready to take it down, I can re-use the fabric elsewhere (shameless DIY post plug)! I actually can’t fathom designing a space without adding a little DIY mojo to the mix. The wall fabric is the foundation of the smaller room, so it should be a fun challenge for me to pick pieces that work well with the existing vibe. But the DIY element in my new bedroom is yet to be determined. One big idea on the brain is: stencils. I’ve been vision boarding a lot lately and find myself continuously drawn to the vintage magazine images of stenciled, folky flowers on the walls (or the ceiling, perhaps?). It’s not necessarily renter-friendly, but I’m a friendly renter and could always paint over it when I leave. But also, I’ve been dying to play with the color stain trend I’ve been seeing everywhere lately and might need to test it out on an older piece of mine that could use a refresh (my garage workshop mentality will never die). It’s a beautiful etagere I’ve been using (and not really loving) in my bathroom, which I think would serve me better in my new big bedroom. Better yet, if the wood was stained…burgundy? Or maybe a denim-y blue? I don’t know! But I want to try. So look out for that DIY sometime down the line. That’s it for now. The grunt work comes first, hopefully followed by clarity and tons of radical vision. I’ll keep you posted as I move the needle. All in due time. Until then… Sincerely, Gretch

Read More